Skip to main content
Title:
Jacob Kruger and Robert Manuel v Her Majesty The Queen
Party:
Canada
Region:
North America
Type of document:
National - higher court
Date of text:
May 31, 1977
Data source:
InforMEA
Court name:
Supreme Court of Canada
Seat of court:
Ottawa
Justice(s):
Laskin; Martland; Judson; Ritchie; Spence; Pigeon; Dickson; Beetz; de Grandpré
Reference number:
[1978] 1 SCR 104
ECOLEX subject(s):
Wild species & ecosystems
Legal questions
Abstract:

In this case, the defendants are two first nations’ hunters who killed a deer outside of the hunting season on a land that used to belong to their tribe but which belongs now to the Crown.

The Crown sued the defendant for violating the provincial Wildlife Act which forbids hunting deer outside the hunting season. The defendants appealed the decision citing their aboriginal rights provided by the 1763 Royal Proclamation. But the British Columbia Court of Appeal, in front of which the appeal was brought, dismissed it on the basis the section 88 of the Indian Act provides that all general laws are applicable to first nation’s people when it does not violate the Indian Act. The Court considered that the Wildlife Act was not violating the Indian Act and that therefore, the two hunters could be charged.

The defendants appealed the decision in front of the Supreme Court. The Judges of the Supreme Court upheld the decision of the lower courts as they considered that no evidence where made to show that the Wildlife Act was not in line with the Indian Act.