Streamlining procedures for describing Ramsar Sites at the time of designation and subsequent updates
1.RECALLING that the Final Act of the 1971 International Conference on the Conservation of Wetlands and Waterfowl in Ramsar, Islamic Republic of Iran, noted the value of collecting supplementary descriptive information on sites included in the List of Wetlands of International Importance, and that Resolution 4.7 (1990) established procedures for the collation of standardised information on Ramsar Sites at the time of their listing, and NOTING that the content and structure of this Ramsar Information Sheet (RIS) has been reviewed and revised by the Conference of the Contracting Parties periodically since 1990;2.ALSO RECALLING that Resolution VI.13 (1996) urged Parties to supply updated information on listed sites whenever there is an actual or potential change in ecological character, and in any case at intervals of no greater than every six years;3.FURTHER RECALLING that Resolution X.15 (2008) established a standardised format for describing and reporting the ecological character of wetlands and outlined the conceptual linkages and overlaps between information on Ramsar Sites collated by different processes established by the Convention;4.AWARE of the resource requirements associated with collating and reporting information on Ramsar Sites both at the time of their listing and subsequent updates, especially for countries with limited capacity or economic limitations, and thus the need for reporting requirements to be highly prioritised, streamlined, and efficient;5.ALSO AWARE, however, that well-organized data and information is fundamental to the delivery of ecologicallyand cost-effective wetland management measures, which are necessary for the continued provision of ecosystem services to human populations and direct economic benefits;6.CONSCIOUS of major advances in information technology and analytical techniques since the establishment of the first RIS format in 1990, and RECALLING that Resolution VIII.13 (2002) requested "the Ramsar [Secretariat] and Wetlands International, working with interested Contracting Parties, to develop protocols for the electronic submission of RISs, where this is possible and desirable, so as to facilitate the supply of data from the information systems of Contracting Parties to the Ramsar Sites Database", and CONCERNED that no progress has yet been made to that end;7.RECALLING the adoption of the Strategic Framework and guidelines for the future development of the List of Wetlands of International Importance of the Convention on Wetlands by Resolution VII.11 (1999) and the adoption, at subsequent meetings of the COP, of additional guidance related to the selection of Ramsar Sites;8.ALSO RECALLING that Resolution X.10, inter alia, requested the Scientific and Technical Review Panel (STRP) to:a)review the consistency, logic, and clarity of the targets and guidelines that support Ramsar’s site selection criteria;b)seek the views of users of the Convention’s guidance on the identification and listing of Wetlands of International Importance;c)review options for revising the format of the RIS seeking to ensure linkages and synergies with other Ramsar instruments to collect and report data and information on listed sites; andd)further consider data and information needs related to the description of ecological character at the point of designation (and assessment of potential change thereafter);9.NOTING Decision X/31 of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) which, inter alia, called on the Ramsar Convention and other interested parties to consider standard criteria for the identification of sites of global biodiversity conservation significance when developing protected-area systems;10.DESIRING to promote synergies and harmonisation between international processes through multiple uses of the same data and information, and NOTING the importance of information on the location, status, and ecological character of Ramsar Sites for the World Database on Protected Areas, the CBD’s Programme of Work on Protected Areas, and other international processes operating at global or international regional scales; and11.NOTING the potential utility of the descriptive information sheet in Annex 1 not only for describing Ramsar Sites at designation and subsequently, but also for inventory, ecological character description, assessment and monitoring (including Article 3.2 reporting) at these and other wetlands;The Conference of the Contracting Parties12.ADOPTS the Ramsar Site Information Sheet (RIS) – 2012 revision as annexed to this Resolution;13.ADOPTS the Strategic Framework and guidelines for the future development of the List of Wetlands of International Importance of the Convention on Wetlands – 2012 revision as annexed to this Resolution as guidance for the future selection and description of Ramsar Sites, both at the time of designation and subsequent updates;14.CONFIRMS that the Ramsar Site Information Sheet (RIS) – 2012 revision and the Strategic Framework and guidelines for the future development of the List of Wetlands of International Importance of the Convention on Wetlands - 2012 revision as annexed to this Resolution supersede and replace the previously adopted Strategic Framework, RIS and other associated guidance for completing the RIS;15URGES Contracting Parties to use the Revised guidelines in their consideration of potential peatland Ramsar Sites as appropriate;16ENCOURAGES Contracting Parties to use all available methods, including remote sensing, to help identify sites as appropriate; and16 bisNOTES the case study included in Annex 2 to the present Resolution, related to the designation of a Wetland of International Importance that has contributed to better public awareness of the role of its peatland resource in relation to climate-change avoidance and mitigation; and RECOGNIZES that there are many other examples of designated Wetlands of International Importance that make the same or similar contributions.17.ENCOURAGES Contracting Parties, on a voluntary basis, to submit new Ramsar Site designations and updates on existing Sites using the RIS – 2012 revision format prior to January 2015, as their capacities allow and following discussion with the Secretariat;19.REQUESTS the Secretariat to work with the CBD, the UNEP-World Conservation Monitoring Centre (UNEP-WCMC), and other organizations to ensure that data and information on the status of Ramsar Sites are fully integrated into other appropriate databases, international processes and assessments;23.EXPRESSES APPRECIATION to the STRP, past and current Secretariat staff, and all those Contracting Parties and others (notably UK’s Joint Nature Conservation Committee, The Nature Conservancy, and Wetlands International) who have contributed to the delivery of the 2012 revisions to the Ramsar Site Information Sheet (RIS) and the Strategic Framework and guidelines for the future development of the List of Wetlands of International Importance of the Convention on Wetlands.Annex 2
Case Study Example: Designation of a peatland as a Ramsar Site using climate mitigation relevance as an additional argument (Lille Vildmose, Denmark)
1.Lille Vildmose is a Ramsar Site, a peatland complex with one of the largest areas of active raised bog in lowland Northwest Europe. The bog was until about 2,500 years ago part of a strait connected to the sea of Kattegat. The landscape elevated due to post-glacial uplifting and eventually the strait was blocked with a brackish lagoon that was covered by nutrient-poor reed swamp. The reed swamp and subsequent development of forest bog were followed by treeless bog of Sphagnum mosses. The sphagnum eventually lost contact with the ground water creating the raised bog that exists at present in Lille Vildmose.2.The bog is currently subject to a large-scale ecological restoration project. Even though the approximately 24 square kilometres (km2) of raised bog is the largest remaining in lowland Northwestern Europe, it is only 40%of its original size. Originally, four lakes covering 400 hectares (ha) were situated in the raised bog: Tofte Sø, Birkesø, Lillesø and Møllesø. These were surrounded by peat habitat having a natural outlet to the sea at Strebæk south of Mulbjerge. Between 1760 and 1769, these lakes were drained and the lake bottoms used for agriculture.3.At that time, handmade channels were excavated over several years, including a channel of about 7 metres deep and 2 km long leading the drainage water to the sea. Two of the lakes (Lille Sø and Tofte Sø) have been restored (one in 1927 and one in 1973) and a third (Birkesø - 130 ha) is in the process of restoration. In contrast to the acid bog, the freshwater lakes in the area have a neutral pH, as they are fed by groundwater springs connected to calcium-rich soil.4.From 1937 to1939, the Danish government acquired 2,300 ha in the central part of the peatland with the objective of creating farmland for small-scale famers. Digging 200 km of ditches improved the drainage and cultivation begun along the eastern border, including for marling, a friable earthy deposit consisting of clay and calcium carbonate used especially as a fertilizer for soils deficient in lime. Lack of fuel during Second World War hampered this project and the northwestern part was sold for peat-extraction and fuel for the local cement-industry. After the war, the cultivated land was found to be rather unattractive. Of 80 planned peatland areas for smallholders, only 36 were sold. Much of the area was turned into grassland and used for summer grazing by domestic animals. The government also started to lease land for peat-extraction. Initially this was mainly for fuel, but later it developed into a highly industrialized extraction of Sphagnum for private and market gardening. Peat extraction stopped in 2011 and today the central part of the Ramsar Site is a mixture of farmland, extensive grassland and recently abandoned open peat-mines in the process of being restored in the sense that the water level has been raised.Management
5.In contrast, the southern part of the Ramsar Site is in a near natural condition as it was fenced, from 1906 to 1907, and set aside as traditional hunting ground for a major estate. A 25-km fence encircled 20 km2 of active raised bog and the adjacent forest of Tofte Skov. Drainage of farmland including dredging of the local stream Haslevgaarde River outside the Ramsar Site has disturbed the fringe of this active bog giving it a drier surface. This in turn has allowed some colonization of birch Betula sp. and conifers adding further to increased evaporation and the creation of shade not otherwise found on the active bog. In addition, this process of scrub development has been stimulated by airborne deposit of nutrients (N) to the oligotrophic bog.6.In the northern part of the Ramsar Site there are two other important areas of raised bogs – both partly degraded. Together with a neighbouring forest (Høstemark Skov), one of these has been another private hunting ground, which was fenced (13 km) from 1933 to 1934. Both forests in the area are predominately lying on moist low-lying land and have significant sectors of fairly old, broadleaf forest.7.After a vision-based planning process, a number of restoration activities have been initiated focusing on the re-establishment of a more natural hydrology, where possible, and facilitation of natural connectivity between the various habitats – forests, lakes, bogs and other open habitats. The restoration activities are funded by both public and private funds. An EU LIFE+ Nature project (2011 to 2018) is partly funding on-going activities.8.Key elements of restoration on the bogs include recreation of the natural water system by ditch blocking and elimination of Birch and other trees over an area of 200 ha. In former peat extraction areas, work to restore the possibility of new bog-formation has involved damming in the drainage-system in order to retain water and/or reduce outflow. Significant areas have been flooded (770 ha). In the forests, the establishment of a natural hydrology has occurred with elimination of conifer plantations (common spruce Picea abies, dwarf pine Pinus mugo, and Sitka spruce Picea sitchensis).9.Parallel to the physical restoration activities, is a large scale on-going grazing project. A third fence around the central area allows trials with free ranging red deer Cervus elaphus and moose Alces alces – the latter a re-introduction to Lille Vildmose and Denmark in 2016. The vision is to combine all three fences allowing free movement of all large herbivores, for example allowing the populations within the southern fence (red deer and wild boar Sus scrofa) and the northern fence (red deer) to merge. The purpose is to use these herbivores as a measure to establish a more natural grazing pressure in the area and thereby keep the area open by limiting the overgrowth of bog vegetation with trees and scrub.10.The Ramsar Site is covered by the largest nature conservation order in Denmark to date to protect its natural, cultural and landscape characteristics and includes 7,513 ha. Furthermore, the area is protected as an EU Natura 2000 site and a management plan has been developed for the entire area with the main aim to restore the raised bog habitat including habitats for endangered and vulnerable species and threatened ecological species communities.Climate mitigation
11.As well as 2,022 ha of active raised bog, the area contains 252 ha of degraded raised bogs still capable of natural regeneration, 1,246 ha of degraded peatland under restoration, 400 ha of bog woodland and 1,000 ha of old natural forest of high biodiversity value on mineral soil. Peat extraction up to 2011 has reduced the area of active raised bog from an original extent of 5,500 ha to its current extent of 2,022 ha.12.Calculations, using the IPCC (2014) default values, arrived at net GHG emissions of 17,780 CO2-eq. yr-1 before the major restoration activities started in 2011 and expect 7,294 CO2-eq. yr-1 after finalizing restoration activities including rewetting of the central and drained parts of Lille Vildmose in 2018.13.The calculated emissions from Lille Vildmose represent c. 1% of the total emissions from peatlands in Denmark and c. 0.02% of the total net human emissions of Denmark (in 2012). It has been estimated that the estimated carbon content in the total peat area of Lille Vildmose is "estimated to be approximately 10% of the total peat carbon volume of 73.6 Mton" in the country (Joosten 2009). Based on these estimates, Lille Vildmose is and will continue to be a net GHG emitting ecosystem, although with smaller fluxes due to rewetting, despite the carbon sequestration taking place (as shown in Table 1).Table 1. Indicative GHG in Lille Vildmose before and after project implementation (emission factors according to IPCC 2014 including the sum of CO2, CH4 and N2O). After Barthelmes et al. 2015.| Land type | Extent (ha) | Emission Factor (ton CO2-eq ha-1 yr-1) before project start | Total emissions (ton CO2-eq yr-1) before project start | Emission Factor (ton CO2-eq ha-1 yr-1) after project | Total emissions (ton CO2-eq yr-1) after project |
| Active raised bog | 2,022 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Degraded raised bog capable of regeneration | 252 | 10 | 2,520 | 3 | 756 |
| Degraded peatland under restoration | 1,246 | 10 | 12,460 | 3 | 3,738 |
| Bog woodland | 400 | 7 | 2,800 | 7 | 2,800 |
| | | | Total 17,780 | | Total 7,294 |
14.Climate change mitigation potential is greatest in heavily degraded sites, such as peatlands that have been profoundly drained and used as cropland. In those cases, rewetting can achieve the largest GHG emissions reductions. These areas may not be as appealing from a biodiversity perspective, as a result, which could hamper their designation as Ramsar Sites. However, it is suggested that when using climate change mitigation as an additional argument to Ramsar Criterion 1, the following considerations are taken into account, which were followed in the case of Lille Vildmose, to designate complexes where:major parts qualify for designation for non-climate related reasons;there are significant areas where restoration will support and strengthen the conservation of adjacent good parts or lead to a substantial emission reductions; and/orwhere national significant peat carbon stocks are present.Communication and awareness
15."Lille Vildmose is one of the most advanced Danish nature areas in terms of nature communication and visitor facilities." A large tourist and visitor centre is centrally situated in the area where wildlife exhibition, films and information activities are showcased. There are guided tours to the peatlands and special education programs for schools during the summer.16.Several boardwalks have been placed at Portlandmosen and Tofte Mose, as well as a number of information boards and watch towers for bird and animal watching. Information boards were placed in eight areas of special interest to the restoration project between 2012 and 2015.17.In 2013, the site was designated as a Ramsar Site using the additional argument for climate regulation for the first time in Ramsar history. The designation was based on two Ramsar Criteria: 1) that the peatland sequesters and stores carbon, and 2) that the bog contains large areas of threatened plant communities that have severely declined in distribution and extent in the relevant biogeographic region, because of large-scale extraction of peat and agricultural land use. Moreover, habitats for vulnerable animal species are present including the golden eagle Aquila chrysaetos, white-tailed sea-eagle Haliaeetus albicilla, common crane Grus grus and Eurasian otter Lutra lutra. Communication and awareness materials have been developed to raise awareness about these assets.18.The area is greatly visited, including by foreign tourists, especially in the summer. A total of 50,000 local visitors, as well as national and international tourists visited the centre in 2014. Since then, and up to 2016, the number increased to 75,000 visitors. It is estimated that twice as many tourists visit the Lille Vildmose Ramsar and Natura 2000 Site annually.19.Although the contribution of Lille Vildmose to global climate regulation may appear small, it plays simultaneously a valuable and active role as an information centre to thousands of people, in Europe and beyond.References
Barthelmes, A., Couwenberg, J., Risager, M., Tegetmeyer, C. and Joosten, H. 2015. Peatlands and Climate in a Ramsar context: A Nordic-Baltic Perspective. Nordic Council of Ministers and Ramsar NorBalWet, Denmark. 244 pp.Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). 2014. 2013 Supplement to the 2006 IPCC Guidelines for National Greenhouse Gas Inventories: Wetlands. Hiraishi, T., Krug, T., Tanabe, K., Srivastava, N., Baasansuren, J., Fukuda, M. and Troxler, T.G. (Eds). IPCC, Switzerland. 354 pp.Joosten, H. 2010. The Global Peatland CO2 Picture. Peatland status and drainage related emissions in all countries of the World. Wetlands International, The Netherlands. 10 pp. {https://www.wetlands.org/publications/the-global-peatland-co2-picture/.Ramsar Convention on Wetlands. 2013. Information Sheet on Ramsar Wetlands (RIS) – 2009-2012 version for Lille Vildmose, Denmark. https://rsis.ramsar.org/RISapp/files/RISrep/DK2166RIS.pdf.Figure 1. Map of Lille Vildmose with the Ramsar site boundary in yellow (designated in 2013). Restoration areas are demarcated in red primarily by reestablishing a natural high water table. Most areas in brown are raised bog vegetation including some restored areas.